is amy lee goth?

[Cockroach Waltz]

I'd say she isn't

when I think goth I think of Peter Murphy, Siouxsie Sioux and Robert Smith.

When I think Ami Lee I think of like a Marilyn Manson.

Someone who just wears black eye make up and uses a lot of dark imagery.

Don't get me wrong, I'm a fan of Marilyn Manson, but I can't stand Evanessance.

Although she is very attractive, she looks nothing like Siouxsie.

 

[Ether-Eating Eskimo]

Evanescence is not a she, it is a band. Amy Lee, the lead singer, is a she. wink  

[Hyatt-Insomnia]

I don't really care, to be honest.
But since you asked, I'd say NO.
She reminds me of 85% of this guild: MALLGOTHS.
[Somebody had to say it.]

 

[GilAskan]

Hyatt-Insomnia

I don't really care, to be honest.
But since you asked, I'd say NO.
She reminds me of 85% of this guild: MALLGOTHS.
[Somebody had to say it.]

Yeah, it may as well be said.  

[Endlos Blut Staub]

She may not be goth, but I love her dresses and skirts and what not. I adore her, and who cares, shes beauitiful, she's talented, *shrugs* I'd do her. She's awesome in my opionon.  

[BlackBloodyDesire]

Goth or not goth. for me it does not matter. As long as she keeps making good songs razz  

[xX x0mbie Xx]

couldnt care less if she was or not, hell i dont even listen to them anymore.  

[PlasticApple]

Yes, I think she is very much. Her music speaks that way if nothing else.  

[GilAskan]

crimsonwhispers

Yes, I think she is very much. Her music speaks that way if nothing else.

Though her music shares some limited lyrical overlap with goth-rock, the actual music itself is not.

And based singularly on that, there is no reason to believe that she is goth.  

[Sanddru]

She is not goth  

[DarkPrincesa]

I'd say she is commercialized goth. I still really enjoy her music and while it is somewhat dark, it is missing something for me... maybe a originality I'm not sure. Although I am surprised as how many "goths" hate her and the group because she could be paving the way for more goth music to become mainstream, which means easier access and more concerts in more places.  

[GilAskan]

DarkPrincesa

I'd say she is commercialized goth. I still really enjoy her music and while it is somewhat dark, it is missing something for me... maybe a originality I'm not sure. Although I am surprised as how many "goths" hate her and the group because she could be paving the way for more goth music to become mainstream, which means easier access and more concerts in more places.

But she isn't actual producing goth-rock. She's just producing mainstream music while fronting goth inspired fashion and aesthetics. If anything, won't that just bring negative attention to goth by making it seem vain in aestheticism?  

[Crematoria]

GilAskan

DarkPrincesa

I'd say she is commercialized goth. I still really enjoy her music and while it is somewhat dark, it is missing something for me... maybe a originality I'm not sure. Although I am surprised as how many "goths" hate her and the group because she could be paving the way for more goth music to become mainstream, which means easier access and more concerts in more places.

But she isn't actual producing goth-rock. She's just producing mainstream music while fronting goth inspired fashion and aesthetics. If anything, won't that just bring negative attention to goth by making it seem vain in aestheticism?

I couldn't agree more.  

[chibi_kasumi_108]

God no. But she sure is talented. And beautiful.

I guess I would say she's her own person outside of labels, like myself.  

[devilsvn]

an edgy, dark appeal, but sadly no. she is very cute, but not really goth. i can see where many have that misconception though.