Trek Vs. ______________

[kyle stabell]

it may be true thet the federation only has one true fighter but it's still HUGE compared to the SW fighters...bellow is a sabre class and then the same pic used to compare the SW ships with the intreped (yes it is still to scale)



 

[kyle stabell]

and now I'm comparing the ST, SW crusers....ST lost this one crying












 

[Steel Sterling]

I'm not in the mood to compare their metric measurements.

However, those are NOT to-scale.

A saber-class fighter is NOT bigger than an AT-AT Walker,
which your first list says.
A saber-class fighter MIGHT be comparable to the Lambda-class
shuttle at the top, but it's probably slightly smaller.

The second list makes the Star Trek ships RIDICULOUSLY SMALL
in comparison to Star Wars.

The capital ships of both are BIG.

The Romulan Warbird (D'deridex) is the largest overall capital ship
of Star Trek. (Unless the Cardassian one is bigger.)
That list has it massing something like 4x that of the Galaxy-class
ships, of which the Enterprise-D is the most famous.
The armaments and defenses of both are comparable,
and the Galaxy-class ships are general-purpose.

I would buy that the Imperial-class Star Destroyers are the size of
the Romulan Warbird, which this DOES show.
The ship at the top is a Super-Star Destroyer.
I'll buy that a Borg Cube and a Super-Star Destroyer are of
comparable mass.
In the movies, there was ONE SSD-the Executor.
The picture does not make it clear this is an SSD, not an
Imperial-class.
The Victory-class Destroyer is smaller than Imperial, and should be
comparable to the USS Rutledge and New Orleans, ST's assault
frigates.  

[kyle stabell]

well the guy that made the site I got these off of said he used the official mesurments given by the makers for the full scale virsions


and the star distroyer at the top is a SSD (and propably is the executor)

and if it helps, the offical mesurments (in length) for the 2 types are 1 mile, and almost 11 miles long (SSD)  

[Se Ga Takai]

If it helps, I have the DS9 RPG(Who didn't see that coming...), and it has the Dimensions for almost all the Ships. It's all Metric, though, so I guess that's one thing that Star Trek has over Star Wars wink

The Largest Ship in the Star Wars Universe(That I have stats for) is teh Dominion Jem'Hadar Battleship. It is roughly twice the size of a Galaxy Class Explorer, and three times as powerful.
1200x800x350m(The tonage and deck amount were left ot of the Description)

The Second largest is the Romulan D'Deridex class Warbird. 1041.65 x 772.43 x 285.47m. 4,320,000 tons, 83 decks.
Reliable intelligence reports indicate that the Romulans power these Ships with an Artificial Singularity--A Microscopic Black Hole. This System Generates incredible amounts of power extremely efficiently; once activated, it can never be shut off(Except with Catastrophic Consequences).

Third is the Negh'Var, the IKDF Flag Ship. 682.32 x 470.09 x 136.65m; 4,310,000 metric tons; 32 Decks.
The Negh'Var is teh Flagship of the Imperial Klingon defense Force. It is a Large Ship armed with 20 Disruptor Arrays, a larger forward disruptor Cannon, and four Torpedo Launchers. It is typically commanded by the Chancellor of the Klingon High Council or his most trusted General.  

[kyle stabell]

Se Ga Takai

If it helps, I have the DS9 RPG(Who didn't see that coming...), and it has the Dimensions for almost all the Ships. It's all Metric, though, so I guess that's one thing that Star Trek has over Star Wars wink

I am way more of a trekie then a SW fan but I did look into the book that had the mesurements and it was in metric and US (the metric #'s were larger)  

[Wind-Whisper]

Trek vs Doctor Who. Might be good.  

[Saoraan]

well in a ST vs SW confrontation ST would have a definitive advantage tech wise over SW. But SW has Jedi and as long as the Q did not get involved that might give them some what of an edge. But in the end ST would certainly win because ST has much better starship tech over SW and after totally crushing the SW space forces ST ships could destroy the SW planets from orbit.