Punk vs. Emo

[finding emotive]

.current.obsession.

finding emotive

.current.obsession.

finding emotive

Retards, this CD is stuffed full of crap yet they say its all Emo, the point is it isn't, not a single song sounds any bit emo, I'm not calling emo crap.

-now u call us retard's.? neutral

Yeah but how do you misunderstand what I first said, its like the time I tried to ask who actually thinks the bands listed on the guild home page are any bit emo and everyone went off saying how you cant really judge weither a band is really emo or not, not a single person answered me.

-well tell me wha' is really, emo to u.? neutral

I always found Emo to be self explanitory, its emotional and hardcore music.  

[heero22]

i dont even kno what this cd is but just stop argueing i mean have u even heard of all the emo thats not even poped up in the scene yet i mean seriously  

[finding emotive]

heero22

i dont even kno what this cd is but just stop argueing i mean have u even heard of all the emo thats not even poped up in the scene yet i mean seriously

You could count scene emo bands on one hand, and emo is almost all I listen to.  

[Blk_Keyblade]

lol, this thread has gone totally off topic...... just say what bands/songs are on the CD u dont think is REALLY emo and we'll tell you what we think..... thats the whole point right?  

[foils]

Blk_Keyblade

lol, this thread has gone totally off topic...... just say what bands/songs are on the CD u dont think is REALLY emo and we'll tell you what we think..... thats the whole point right?

-doesn't mean we can't discuss other issues.  

[x Pershion x]

punks are too angery, emos are too sad, and scene kids are too self lovieng...you can't win confused
personally, i choose emo, atlest they wont yell at you..... i hate being yelled at ... cry  

[finding emotive]

Right so the list of bands is like this:

1. This Time Is The Last Time - Mae
2. Set It Off - Rufio
3. Smile - Onelinedrawing
4. Good Old Days, The - Anti-Anti
5. Kickin' It Under - 5 Cent Deposit
6. Last Good Part Of Town - Fallout Boy
7. Or Else - 504plan
8. Come Back - The Early November
9. Potty Mouth - The Huntingtons
10. Real You, The - Eiffel Rev
11. Let Go - Near Miss
12. Let It Go - The Goodwill
13. Bloody Night, Bloody Knife - The Independents
14. Chocs Away - Snuff
15. Ones For You - Stereotyperider
16. Railroad - Project Bluebook
17. Average - Armstrong
18. Brandywine - Belvedere
19. Insincerity As An Artform - Further Seems Forever
20. Drag - Adventures Of Jet
21. Never Forget The Ramones - Goin' Places
22. Like White Noise - Gamits
23. Learn Your Lesson - Punchline
24. No Regrets - Divit

The only one I've ever heard of is Fall Out Boy, and they arn't even emo.  

[The Brand New]

I heard of Mae. Never really listended to them. The rest suck.  

[[Interlude]]

Saito_Style

I heard of Mae. Never really listended to them. The rest suck.

Word.  

[SlayerofEvil]

finding emotive

[Putcoolnamehere]

What bands are really emo?

there's no real answer to this question.
If the people that made the cd like what they hear.
It's their choice to label it 'emo' if they think it is.

Thats not true, especially if its not hardcore, I'm not saying all the songs have to be but if they're at all not then its not really an Emotive Hardcore CD then is it?

But who truly decides what is and isn't emo. PEOPLE!!! people are falable. People decide what is and isn't emo and we choose whether or not to follow that. in my opinion we should all choose for ourselves what is and isn't emo, other wise we're just just a bunch of mindless drones following a leader. we all need to decide these things for ourselves.  

[butterflies_sweet_kisses]

i listen to the music i want to, if yall want to label it go ahead, it makes no differance to me.  

[x The Emo Cat x]

[Straw Dog]

Saito_Style

I heard of Mae. Never really listended to them. The rest suck.

Word.

man, what's up with emos saying s**t like 'werd' 'dawg' 'yo' etc.
why are emos acting all gansta (and shyt)?? i don't get it...but lately I'VE been doing it too!! and i donno why... confused  

[trishxxcore]

I like the early november, and anyways.
Honestly.
Emo emo emo emo.
Its what everyone wants to be, yet the big argument is what it is.

Honestly, with the media and s**t. It's hard to know these days.

Not concluding that i know and you guys don't.. Just it's hard these days to know what's real and what's not.

So all there is left is for us to have our own opinions.

My opinion is the "emo" people make it out to be these days is over rated, like MCR for example, but old 80's emo, such as Portraits of the Past are more real to me.

But like I said.
It's my opinion, and I respect yours.  

[finding emotive]

You do have to have a certain sound to be emo, just like to be any other genre. I dont know how so many people can be in an emo guild and not know what real emo is.