Which Pokemon did you start out with?

[Poppikachu]

Red: Charmander
Blue: Squirtle
Green: Bulbasaur
Gold: Chikorita
Silver: Totodile
Crystal: Cyndaquil
Ruby: Treecko
Sapphire: Mudkip
Emerald: Torchic
FireRed: Bulbasaur
LeafGreen: Charmander
Diamond: Turtwig
Pearl: Turtwig  

[Negai Boshi]

Red: Charmander
Blue (I chose the starter, then gave the game to my sister): Squirtle
Yellow: Pikachu (duh, but I would have chosen Charmander)
Silver: Cyndaquil
Gold (same situation as Blue): Chikorita
Sapphire: Treecko
Ruby: Mudkip
Emerald: Torchic
Emerald: Torchic (yeah, I have two....)
FireRed: Charmander
LeafGreen (same situation as Blue and Gold): Bulbasaur
Diamond: Chimchar

I like the fire types the best, but I tried to get different ones within each generation so I could trade. Charmander's still my favorite of al the starters because Charizard can fly.  

[pooka91 v2]

Red: Charmander
Blue: Squirtle
Yellow: Pikachu
Silver: Cyndaquil
Gold:totodile
Sapphire: Treecko
Ruby: torchic
Emerald: mudkip
FireRed: Charmander
LeafGreen:Bulbasaur  

[Neppeta]

Crystal: Cyndaquil
Ruby: Torchic
Sapphire: mudkip
Emerald: Treeko
Diamond: Chimchar
LeafGreen: Bulbasaur
Firered: Squirtle  

[Hellz Shadow]

I always choose the fire starter, but I MAY make an exception for Totodile or Bulbasaur.  

[blue_man_of_destruction]

Blue:Charmander
Gold:Cydaquil
Crystal:Totodile
Sapphire,Ruby,Emerald:Chicorita
Diamond:Chimchar  

[xSuiMiki]

Firered: Bulbasaur
Ruby: Mudkip
Emerald: Treeko
Pearl: Chimchar  

[froggie of pwnage]

red: charmander
Ruby: treeko
firered: squritle
pearl: chimchar  

[fluffmarsh]

Blue: Squirtle
Gold: Chikorita
Yellow: Pikachu lol.  

[SceptileKittyGirl]

Blue: Squirtle
Red: Charmander
Yellow: Pikachu, duh
Silver: Cyndaquil
Gold: Totodile
Crystal: Cyndaquil again
Sapphire: Torchic
Diamond: Piplup

Wow, no Grass starters. sweatdrop  

[xDepressionXHappinessx]

Red: Charmander
Blue: Squirtle
Yellow: Pikachu
Silver: Cyndaquil
Gold :Cyndaquil
Sapphire: Treecko
Ruby: Mudkip
Emerald: Torchic
FireRed: Bulbasaur
LeafGreen: Squirtle
Diamond: Piplup  

[Tohru_Handa_San]

yellow:pikachu
c/g/s/:cindaquill,chikorita
d/p: piplup
gl/charmander
s/r/e:torchic  

[Hellz Shadow]

Hellz Shadow

I always choose the fire starter, but I MAY make an exception for Totodile or Bulbasaur.

Eh, might as well make a list thing.
Red: Charmander
Blue: Charmander...
Yellow: Take a guess, genius.
Gold: Cyndaquil
Silver: All 3 (used cloning glitch, hard to explain how I got em all on one file)
Crystal: Cyndaquil
Ruby:Torchic
Emerald: Torchic
FireRed: Charmander, Charmander, Bulbasaur (Dif files)
Diamond: Chimchar (Whom I'm not a great fan of :/)

Johto games rocked. Emerald rocked. Yellow rocked. Diamond I haven't gotten to thinking it rocks yet.  

[Deadgirll]

Silver:Cyndaquil
Crystal: Totodile
Emerald: Treecko  

[Uyraies]

Blue: Bulbasaur
Red: Bulbasaur, then Charmander after a reset
Yellow: ...Pikachu. xD
Silver: Totodile
Gold: Cyndaquil
Crystal: Totodile
Sapphire: Torchic
Leaf Green: Bulbasaur (Ah, nostalgia. <3)
Pearl: Chimchar.