Street light VS. Catch22

[ScornX]

ok im a huge street light fan but i love old catch and i was wondering allaround who do yo ulike better and who did KESBY better in your mind  

[koolbeanzkt]

i cant decide :/  

[Electric Uncle Akuma]

I'd say Streetlight.
For a few reasons.

1: Tomas Kalnoky is writting the music, and lyrics. He's my favorite composer, singer, guitarist, and lyricist.
2: Horn arrangment. I prefer their set up to Catch 22's.
3: Style. Same genre, much different style of playing live, and on albums.
4: Talent. I'm NOT saying Catch 22 is untalent DO NOT think that. I'm saying I like the talent in Streetlight. As in Delano Bonner, and Mike Soprano.
5: I prefer Kalnoky's voice to Ryan Eldred's and Kevin Gunther's.

So, Catch is under Streetlight, but only by one peg.  

[Cue-Cue]

I'd say Streetlight, as I'm a huge fan of them. Not to say Catch 22 is bad, as I enjoy them very much. I just think Streetlight's sound is much more...clean. That's not the best way to describe it, but that's how it is to me.

So, Streetlight.  

[King Of The Ska]

Catch22 for 1 reason and 1 reason only.
They were my first ska band
They were the band that got me to who I am today.
Without their songs, I wouldn't be me ><
So as much as I love Streetlight, I will always love Catch22 ( except their new stuff, it ******** sucks) heart

Keasby Nights was my first c.d
I listened to that thing until I played it out, then bought a new copy  

[Cue-Cue]

I think that's kinda why I lean towards Streetlight as well. They were one of the first ska bands I heard, and I loved their sound. And that's what got me into it.

Can't wait to go to their show.  

[Asthen]

Catch did Keasby Nights better, imo, but I like Streetlight better overall.  

[Queenie42]

Street Light had a lack of charisma onstage. But Catch 22 had a better version and name.  

[BLANK-DELETE-BLANK]

I like them both about the same. Especially after listening to Permanent Revolution. Although, after the video shoot on saturday, i dont know how soon i will listen to "Party Song" again though, but the shoot was sick, it was basically us chilling with them for 4 hours.  

[skamatt]

ode to optimism

Catch did Keasby Nights better, imo, but I like Streetlight better overall.

Wow I think when Kalnoky did it with streetlight they made it soo much better and I love the newer version of riding the 4th wave, mostly for the trumpet solo.

but yeah Im going to say streetlight on this topic. I just think Tomas Kalnoky is god. period ens of that subject for me  

[Crimson_And_Clover]

Catch 22 all the way.  

[ScornX]

yea feed back and i like Catch 22's kesbey better but streetlight overall better  

[Cursed Ronin]

Catch 22 did a better Keasby Nights but I do like Streetlight better. Everything Goes Numb just won me over to Streetlight. sweatdrop  

[Cue-Cue]

I'm about even at this point. Both versions have alot to offer in my opinion. Riding the 4th Wave has to be my favorite song on the album.  

[ScornX]

i dont know point counter point and a better place a better time just cought me