Secret Valentine. Do we want fakes in this guild?

[Pixelated-Kawaii]

Okay, guys. Just a basic poll for you guys. The question is this:


Do you think that the fake valentine gifters should stay or do they have to go?


Note: Just to clarify things. Those people in question will be given 1 whole week to contact me regarding the matter. I think this is quite enough time to send me one simple PM, with their explanation.  

[felinophiles alter ego]

first voter biggrin
momo i love your hat eek ive never seen that before  

[bronxbigred]

if they knew the rules before hand then they have 2 go
just send the gifts and all will be good


bronx bump  

[Felinophile]

all you have to do is grab a few tanks and you can buy your gift, now get going biggrin  

[Pixelated-Kawaii]

felinophiles alter ego

first voter biggrin
momo i love your hat eek ive never seen that before

It's been around for a while now. It's called TLDR hat  

[Pixelated-Kawaii]

Felinophile

all you have to do is grab a few tanks and you can buy your gift, now get going biggrin

Ikr, that's what I've been thinking. I mean 5k is chump change.  

[Seductive Strawberries]

I swear, Some people suck and ruin events for others.
I have proof I sent mine in my Gift History. :3
http://awesomescreenshot.com/0bcueqx51
You are welcome, I want you to know, it is almost after v-day anyway.  

[glengrin]

If someone signed up and deliberately did not send a gift, they should be banned. But if someone was unable to today because they were not able to be online, or just forgot, they should be given the chance to make it good.  

[Pixelated-Kawaii]

glengrin

If someone signed up and deliberately did not send a gift, they should be banned. But if someone was unable to today because they were not able to be online, or just forgot, they should be given the chance to make it good.

I also agree with this, which is why I am giving people until Monday next week. Also, if people don't respond to any messages that I have and will be sending, I am most likely going to take that as an attempt to evade the situation. So I am giving people the chance and opportunity to explain themselves.  

[glengrin]

Peachy_Girl_Momo

glengrin

If someone signed up and deliberately did not send a gift, they should be banned. But if someone was unable to today because they were not able to be online, or just forgot, they should be given the chance to make it good.

I also agree with this, which is why I am giving people until Monday next week. Also, if people don't respond to any messages that I have and will be sending, I am most likely going to take that as an attempt to evade the situation. So I am giving people the chance and opportunity to explain themselves.

That seems most fair; plenty of time. All they need to do is check their pm's.  

[The Madlib Hatter]

It's my personal opinion that you should have dealt with the matter with the people involved quietly, and not alerted the entire guild to the situation. It's not that huge of a deal if it's only a 5k gift, that's like 2 or 3 mid- to high-tier tanks you can grab. This whole situation doesn't need a guild-wide announcement and a poll about it, it's only 3 members who probably haven't had a chance to get online yet and will be quite upset that such a huge deal was made out of such a little thing.  

[ACHgirl]

The people that have not sent the gifts, has anyone checked to see if they have been online? Banning them seems kind of harsh if they have not logged on recently.  

[Arch Angel Neko]

Check if they have been able to log on. But besides that. I think its not cool to not send your gift to your valentine. It's not a big amount anyway. 3nodding *slaps those non gifters a** with a mallet* get your a** moving guys! smile we are bg players y'know  

[Arch Angel Neko]

The Madlib Hatter

It's my personal opinion that you should have dealt with the matter with the people involved quietly, and not alerted the entire guild to the situation. It's not that huge of a deal if it's only a 5k gift, that's like 2 or 3 mid- to high-tier tanks you can grab. This whole situation doesn't need a guild-wide announcement and a poll about it, it's only 3 members who probably haven't had a chance to get online yet and will be quite upset that such a huge deal was made out of such a little thing.

*thumbs up for this*  

[ll Fatal Charades ll]

As I am reading this only one day after Valentine's day it would seem a bit premature to assume that they are scamers. Not everyone is as active on Gaia as others, and they may not have had time to log in and participate yet... However, they were made aware of the rules of this event and if they have still not complied with them within a set amount of time then the rules should be enforced.